Very Large Charges From Bader
Moderator: moderators
Very Large Charges From Bader
I have been trying to run a bader analysis on my system, but every time I do I get large positive charges. I am using VASP and run `chgsum.pl AECCAR0 AECCAR2` then run `bader CHGCAR -ref CHGCAR_sum`. INCAR also attached. I get similarly bad results when I use cube files from quantum espresso (though not the same results.)
- Attachments
-
- ACF.txt
- (4.11 KiB) Downloaded 1675 times
Re: Very Large Charges From Bader
INCAR did not attach to original post.
- Attachments
-
- INCAR.txt
- (221 Bytes) Downloaded 1394 times
Re: Very Large Charges From Bader
What you are looking at is not the net charge - it is the number of valence electrons associated with each atom. To get the net charge, you need to take the (positive) nuclear charge and subtract the charge in the ACF file. I can't see what atoms you have in your system, but let's say that the first element is a second column element with two valence electrons. Then the nuclear charge (not including what is modeled by the pseudopotential) is +2 and the net charge will be +2 - 1.924 = +0.076.
Re: Very Large Charges From Bader
thanks graeme!